The Wandering Goose: A Seattle Comfort Food Institution
Last Updated on December 29, 2024 by Daniel Williams
As a longtime Capitol Hill resident who has witnessed Seattle’s culinary landscape evolve over the past decade, few establishments have captured my heart quite like The Wandering Goose. This beloved Southern-inspired café, which first opened its doors at 403 15th Avenue East in 2012, became synonymous with buttermilk biscuits, fried chicken, and genuine Southern hospitality in the Pacific Northwest.
The Journey
Chef Heather Earnhardt, originally from North Carolina, brought authentic Southern recipes and techniques to Seattle, transforming a modest 1,000-square-foot space into what would become one of Capitol Hill’s most cherished breakfast and lunch spots. The restaurant’s name, inspired by a children’s story Earnhardt wrote, perfectly captured the whimsical yet purposeful nature of her culinary journey.
The Wandering Goose Original Location & Atmosphere (2012-2020)
The original Capitol Hill location was intimate, seating only 25 people at its peaked-ceiling counter and communal tables. The space’s charm lay in its rustic details: vintage plates adorning white walls, mason jar light fixtures, and the constant aroma of freshly baked pastries and brewing coffee.
Menu Highlights & Pricing Analysis
| Category | Signature Item | Price Range (2019) | Comparable Seattle Spots | Their Price Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Biscuit Sandwiches | Fried Chicken Biscuit | $12-14 | Biscuit Box | $11-13 |
| Serious Biscuit | $12-15 | |||
| Sweet Treats | Cake Slices | $8-10 | Deep Sea Sugar | $7-9 |
| Macrina Bakery | $8-11 | |||
| Breakfast Plates | Grits & Eggs | $13-15 | Fat’s Chicken | $14-16 |
| Square Knot Diner | $12-14 |
Signature Recipes at The Wandering Goose
The restaurant’s fame largely rested on several key items:
- Buttermilk Biscuits: Made fresh daily using a generations-old recipe featuring White Lily flour
- Fried Chicken: 24-hour buttermilk brine, double-dredged and pressure-fried
- Grits: Stone-ground, slow-cooked for 3 hours with heavy cream and butter
- Layer Cakes: Rotating selection of 5-7 daily varieties, each standing 12 inches tall
The Closure and Revival
In December 2020, amid the challenges of the COVID-19 pandemic, The Wandering Goose announced its permanent closure of the Capitol Hill location. However, the story didn’t end there. In spring 2021, Earnhardt brought back The Wandering Goose’s beloved recipes through pop-ups at her other venture, The Tokeland Hotel on Washington’s coast.
Legacy and Impact
The Wandering Goose significantly influenced Seattle’s breakfast scene, inspiring several Southern-style establishments that followed. Its impact can be measured in several ways:
- Served approximately 1,200 biscuits weekly during peak operations
- Trained over 25 bakers who went on to open their own establishments
- Featured in over 30 local and national publications
- Earned consistent 4.5/5 stars on review platforms
- Named among Seattle Met’s top 100 restaurants three years running
The Wandering Goose Current Operations
Today, while the original Capitol Hill location remains a fond memory, The Wandering Goose lives on through special events at The Tokeland Hotel and through Earnhardt’s cookbook, “Big Food Big Love,” which features many of the restaurant’s beloved recipes. Weekend pop-ups at the hotel regularly sell out, drawing loyal customers from Seattle who make the 2.5-hour drive to the coast for their biscuit fix.
The Future
While rumors occasionally surface about a potential Seattle comeback, Earnhardt has found a new home for The Wandering Goose’s spirit on the coast. The pop-ups and special events continue to evolve, incorporating local coastal ingredients while maintaining the soul of the original recipes that made the Capitol Hill location legendary.
For those of us who called The Wandering Goose our regular breakfast spot, its influence extends beyond mere nostalgia. It demonstrated how a small, focused establishment could create an outsized impact on a city’s culinary scene through authenticity, quality, and unwavering dedication to craft.
Source:
